Fifth Avenue, 5 A.M.: Audrey Hepburn, Breakfast at Tiffany's, and the Dawn of the Modern Woman

Name: Fifth Avenue, 5 A.M.: Audrey Hepburn, Breakfast at Tiffany's, and the Dawn of the Modern Woman
Author: Sam Wasson

by Sam Wasson

Premium

History

Biography

Arts

“The story of how a cinematic icon transformed a call girl into a cultural heroine, redefining femininity at the cusp of the sexual revolution.”

Key Takeaways

1Holly Golightly was a radical sanitization for Hollywood. The film transformed Capote's tragic, morally ambiguous call girl into a 'kooky' romantic heroine, navigating strict censorship to make her palatable.
2Audrey Hepburn's casting was a profound act of alchemy. Her inherent goodness and gamine charm allowed audiences to accept a sexually liberated character they would have rejected from any other actress.
3The little black dress became a uniform for independence. Givenchy's design, as worn by Hepburn, transcended fashion to symbolize a new, sophisticated, and self-possessed urban femininity.
4The film's creation was a cascade of fortunate accidents. From the last-minute salvation of 'Moon River' to the fraught casting decisions, the classic we know was perpetually on the brink of failure.
5It captured a precise moment of cultural liminality. The film straddled the conservative 1950s and the liberated 1960s, offering a blueprint for a new kind of single woman in the city.
6Truman Capote's vision was fundamentally betrayed. The author loathed the film adaptation, which replaced his novella's melancholy realism with Hollywood romance and a heterosexual love interest.

Description

Sam Wasson's 'Fifth Avenue, 5 A.M.' is not merely a making-of chronicle but a cultural excavation of the 1961 film 'Breakfast at Tiffany's.' It begins with the genesis of Truman Capote's 1958 novella, a character study of Holly Golightly, a charming, rootless call girl in New York City. Wasson traces the real-life socialites and Capote's own mother who inspired Holly, and details the author's fervent desire to see Marilyn Monroe—not Audrey Hepburn—embody the role's raw, voluptuous potential. Wasson then meticulously charts the fraught journey from page to screen, a process demanding radical transformation to satisfy the Hollywood Production Code. Screenwriter George Axelrod and director Blake Edwards faced the herculean task of softening Holly's profession into vague 'kookiness,' while converting the narrator—a gay writer based on Capote himself—into the straight, romantic lead Paul Varjak. The narrative delves into the pivotal contributions of costume designer Hubert de Givenchy, whose little black dress became an eternal icon, and composer Henry Mancini, whose 'Moon River' nearly faced studio rejection. The book presents the film's production as a high-wire act of collaborative genius and conflict, highlighting Hepburn's personal anxieties about the role, George Peppard's difficult on-set behavior, and the enduring controversy of Mickey Rooney's racist caricature. Wasson argues that the film's alchemy—Hepburn's innocence grafted onto a risqué premise—created a permissible fantasy of female independence. It offered a new model of womanhood that was stylish, single, and sexually aware, yet remained fundamentally lovable, thus paving a mainstream path for the social changes of the coming decade.

Community Verdict

The community consensus is sharply divided, reflecting a tension between adoration for the subject and critique of the execution. Enthusiasts, often Hepburn devotees, praise the book as a delicious, anecdote-rich dive into a beloved film's creation, revelling in the insider details of casting, costume design, and Hollywood politics. They find it witty, well-researched, and a compelling argument for the film's cultural significance. A significant contingent of readers, however, finds the book's substance lacking. Critics accuse Wasson of overreaching with his thesis, arguing that he fails to convincingly substantiate the claim that 'Breakfast at Tiffany's' alone heralded 'the dawn of the modern woman.' They describe the prose as glib, superficial, and stylistically grating, more akin to a lengthy magazine feature than a serious work of cultural history. Others feel the narrative is disjointed, skipping between topics without depth, and relying on a gossipy tone that undermines its analytical ambitions.

Hot Topics

1The debate over the book's central thesis: whether 'Breakfast at Tiffany's' genuinely catalyzed the modern woman or merely reflected broader cultural shifts already in motion.
2Analysis of Holly Golightly's character, contrasting Capote's tragic, complex call girl with the film's sanitized, romanticized 'kook.'
3The transformative power of Audrey Hepburn's casting and persona, which made an otherwise controversial character acceptable to a mainstream audience.
4The controversial and racist portrayal of Mr. Yunioshi by Mickey Rooney, and its lasting stain on the film's legacy.
5The intricate behind-the-scenes drama of the film's production, including fraught casting decisions and the battle to save 'Moon River.'
6The iconic cultural impact of Givenchy's little black dress as a symbol of independent, sophisticated femininity.